At potentially $7,500 per person, Veterans Affairs Minister Julian Fantino’s Cyprus junket cost just over $100,000 for 14 individuals.
By SEAN BRUYEA | Published: Monday, 03/17/2014 12:00 am EDT
On March 12, 2014, the flag lowered in Kabul, Canada’s most costly mission since World War II. Not a single Conservative MP attended. The next day, Veterans Affairs Minister Julian Fantino flew to Cyprus to commemorate the UN mission’s 50th anniversary.
In an email, Veterans Affairs Canada indicated Fantino would be accompanied by “a staff member, five veterans from the Canadian Peacekeeping Veterans Association, five veterans from the Canadian Association of Veterans in United Nations Peacekeeping and two program officials.”
Retired captain Perry Gray was contingent commander in Cyprus from 1996-1998. He is chief editor of VeteranVoice.info, an internet community of 100,000 subscribers. “Why are they going to Cyprus? It is unresolved, a black mark. Nicosia is the only remaining divided capital of Europe,” said Gray, adding, “we were never consulted on this trip.”
It appears that only CPVA and CAVUNP were asked to nominate individuals. CAVUNP had approximately 375 members in January 2013 and CPVA is considerably smaller. However, both would not respond to repeated email questions about the trip or their membership numbers, which include more than just peacekeeping veterans.
VeteransofCanada.ca (VOC) is a community of more than 7,500 members with at least 640 peacekeeping veterans. Don Leonardo, president and founder of VOC, said his organization was not consulted, “We are in budget constraints. It’s a matter of priorities. Couldn’t that money have been allocated to help prevent suicide, provide greater benefits, makes changes to the New Veterans Charter?”
Veterans Affairs declined to provide any cost estimate for the seven-day trip, but confirmed “VAC is paying the full cost of airfare, travel, accommodation and daily incidentals for the 10 [veterans].”
In 2013, Fantino billed $5,173.54 for a two-day trip to London and $9,306.37 for three days in Korea. At potentially $7,500 per person, Cyprus could cost just over $100,000 for 14 individuals.
Jerry Kovacs, of Canadian Veterans Advocacy, said his organization was not consulted. “The optics look bad…budget cutbacks, office closures, staff reductions and then you have a junket to Cyprus during March break while it’s snowing and cold. Who’s advising this guy? The money is better spent elsewhere, like on veterans, especially the homeless, their families, research on helping veterans, service dogs; you know, on services that directly benefit veterans and their families.”
For the 2014 commemoration of 70 years since D-Day, Canada has allocated funding for 180 veterans at $2,000 each. The Conservative government has come under attack for its commemoration of the dead while the injured and their families remain neglected.
Commemoration for the War of 1812 ran to more than $28-million.
In a presentation during a meeting with veteran organizations in October 2013, Fantino failed to mention the planned trip to Cyprus.
A PowerPoint slide indicated, “The large majority of Canadians [89 per cent] believe that the service of post-war or modern-day veterans should be recognized.”
How are Canadians to recognize, let alone participate 8,600 km from Ottawa where a captivatingly haunting peacekeeping monument rests silently? Could not a fraction of that money host a brief outdoor ceremony at the monument followed by hundreds of Cyprus veterans and the public including children on March break expressing appreciation in many of the nearby conference venues?
The Royal Canadian Legion is Canada’s largest veteran organization, with more than 90,000 post-WWII veterans. At least 3,500 of its members served in Cyprus.
Dominion Secretary Brad White wrote in an email to me, “[t]he legion was not consulted on the commemoration trip to Cyprus, nor does it know of the intended plans,” adding, “[t]here does need to be a balance on how much is spent as compared to the amount of monies set aside to look after those who have been injured in the service of their country.”
Why were only two organizations asked to provide candidates? On its website, CPVA, one of the organizations sending five individuals, indicates CPVA organized two previous commemoration trips in 2011 and 2012 wherein they intended to seek funding from VAC.
During VAC stakeholder meetings in February and December 2012, president of CAVUNP, Ron Griffis, advocated for a trip to Cyprus.
Mike Blais, president and founder of CVA, was seriously injured in Cyprus; “Our time in the meetings would have been better served focusing solely on the real issues such as seriously injured veterans and their families rather than commemoration. I do not think [VAC] should have approached this on an organizational level. VAC has an obligation to the wounded. They should have offered the injured the opportunity to go back. Instead [the wounded] were largely abandoned.”
Ron Cundell, webmaster of VeteranVoice.info, said he remembers Griffis advocating for the Cyprus trip. “Are you the president of your veteran organization to improve veterans’ quality of life or for free trips?”
It is sad that government forces veterans to scavenge for fiscal scraps. It is equally sad that some veterans willingly participate in this trip.
Sean Bruyea is vice-president of Canadians for Accountability, a retired Air Force intelligence officer and frequent commentator on government, military, and veterans’ issues.
The Hill Times
Comment: The Department has provided the names of those 10 individuals on the trip via a Flickr photo. Contrary to the Department’s statement, it appears that CAVUNP was allowed to send six individuals and CPVA four.
Did you serve in Cyprus?
Were you asked to go?:
Ronald Griffis (CAVUNP National President)
Richard Wright (CAVUNP National Vice President)
William Greensides (CAVUNP National Secretary and Treasurer)
Alain Forand (CAVUNP-Maj. General Retired)
Kevin Hollohan (CAVUNP)
Edward Widenmaier (CAVUNP-Warrant Officer Retired)
Larry Gollner (CPVA Patron-Brig. General Retired)
Timothy Sparling (CPVA Representative in Ottawa-Colonel Retired)
Gary Best (CPVA Regional Chair Newfoundland and Labrador)
Wayne Kennedy (CPVA Membership Director)
Sources for purposes of identifying individuals on trip:
www.cavunp.org (accessed March 17 2014)
www.cpva.ca (accessed March 17 2014)
http://www.kvacanada.com/newsletterpdf/july02a2012newsletter.pdf (accessed March 17 2014)
http://www.cpva.ca/documents_e/cpva/bios/larry_gollner.pdf (accessed March 17 2014)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alain_Forand (accessed March 17 2014)